social media, web 2.0

To RT or Not to RT?

Comments 19 November 2009

To RT or Not to RT?

Many people have been talking about twitter’s new RT beta feature and it may seem like most people don’t like it. But I thought I would throw my 2 cents in the ring about what I think of the feature.

In case you are unaware, Twitter is rolling out an official retweet feature that is in beta right now. It allows users to RT with just one click (no more copying and pasting tweets), and it provides a way for people to easily see how much their tweets are being retweeted.

Now there are some obvious drawbacks to this. The new feature only lets you RT the tweet as it was originally written, you can’t modify it or add your comments. For some people this is a drawback, but for others it’s a plus.

It’s a drawback if you frequently like adding comments to the things you RT, and it could be positive because tweets no longer need to be short enough to add your username to be “re-tweet-able”. A tweet that is exactly 140 characters can easily be retweeted now, where in the past it would have needed to be shortened to allow space for RT @that persons username.

twitter RT_s

One reason that I like the new RT feature is that it helps to regulate fake RT’s and is a great way to discover new people to follow.

A few things I would change:

1. Avatar correction. I would want the avatar to be the person that I am following who is choosing to share this information with me. After all, the people I follow are people that I trust. So seeing what they retweeted to their followers should be reflected by showing their avatar in my timeline.

2. RT alerts. Similar to the way that Tumblr shows users alerts when someone else has liked or reblogged your post. If a simple one line alert showed up in my timeline letting me know that my tweet had been retweeted it would make the whole process easier and more encouraging for users.

Tumblr notes

3. 3rd party support! Currently desktop and iphone apps are not taking advantage of the RT feature because it is so new. There is no place in tweetdeck or tweetie for me to see my retweets the same way I would see @replies. In fact, if someone retweets a tweet that has my username in it using the official RT function, that tweet won’t show up in my @replies of a 3rd party client at all.

The fact is that it will be very hard for twitter to rope in a feature that was created by the users and standerdize it. That can’t force you to stop retweeting the old way, so they new way will be hard for people to adopt.

What are your thoughts on the new feature?

Let me know in the comments.

  • I read your profile today and it was so good to me.i feel you are the only one missing in my entire life so i decided to stop on and let you know that i am interested to be a friend first.When the fight begins within himself, a man's worth something
  • johncabrera
    My feeling are very similar to yours. I don't really mind so much not being able to add comments... you can still do retweets the old way, after all... but I don't like seeing people in my stream that I'm not following. In that moment, I imagine the person I actually am following is gone and has been replaced by this other person. A simple change of the avatar (or maybe even some reformatting that includes two avatars) is def the way to go.

    As for iPhone: Twittelator Pro. Best iPhone twitter client by far in terms of features. The guy(s) who develop that app are always at the front of the pack in leveraging new apis. They've had RTs labeled and compartmentalized within the app for weeks it seems. Twitter let developers start working with the RT feature at least month before they started the beta themselves. Twittelator was actually letting you do auto retweets for weeks before the official beta roll out.

    I know this post is from a couple weeks back... but I've wanted to weigh in on this too.
  • heathersh
    I'm with you on all of your suggestions - especially the one about the avatar displayed being that of the retweeter, not that of the original tweeter. I don't like avatars of people I'm not following showing up in my feed. I kind of like though that you can't alter the retweet. I know a lot of people don't generate much new content, they just add their own remarks to the retweeted content. Forces us to find original content to tweet if we want the credit.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Welcome!

Thanks for visiting my blog!

It might look a little different since the last time you saw it, but take a look around and let me know what you think!

Looking for more about me?
Check out the About Me page.

Subscribe

 Subscribe in a reader

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

  • Twitter

    Photos on flickr

    Friend me up!

    Twitter  Flickr  Delicious  FriendFeed  Facebook  Viddler  Last.fm  LinkedIn  Tumblr  Google Reader  Meetup  Yelp  

    © 2009 Random Sarah. Powered by Wordpress.

    Daily Edition Theme by WooThemes - Premium Wordpress Themes